IaaS vs PaaS vs SaaS: Which Cloud Model Fits?

Choose software as a service (SaaS) when an existing application fits your workflow. Choose platform as a service (PaaS) when you need to build an application but want a provider to manage the platform. Choose infrastructure as a service (IaaS) when the workload needs lower-level control and your team can operate it.

TL;DR


  • SaaS supplies a ready-to-use application; PaaS runs your custom application on a managed platform; IaaS supplies infrastructure you configure.
  • Start with SaaS for a standard workflow, PaaS for a custom app that fits the platform, and IaaS when you need operating-system control.
  • Google Workspace, Cloud Run and Compute Engine illustrate the three models; each product's terms set its actual boundaries.
  • Your team still owns users, permissions and data decisions in every model, even when the provider operates more of the stack.
  • In one hypothetical 10-user workflow, first-year costs are $4,100 for SaaS, $11,360 for PaaS and $13,520 for IaaS under the stated assumptions.
  • A lower infrastructure bill can cost more overall when application support, server maintenance and staff time are included.

The choice changes both the work the provider does and the work your team must own. The National Institute of Standards and Technology defines these as cloud service models. They are different from public, private and hybrid cloud, which describe how infrastructure is deployed.

What is the difference between IaaS, PaaS, and SaaS?

ModelProvider suppliesYour team typically ownsExample
SaaSThe application and its underlying serviceUsers, permissions, settings, data use and the business workflowGoogle Workspace
PaaSA managed environment for deploying applicationsApplication code, configuration, data, access and integrationsGoogle Cloud Run
IaaSComputing, storage and networking infrastructureThe guest operating system, installed software, application, data and accessGoogle Compute Engine virtual machines

These examples follow Google Cloud’s service-model comparison. A provider can offer more than one model, and a company can use all three. A PaaS application might call a SaaS tool while another workload runs on an IaaS virtual machine.

The table is a starting point, not a substitute for service-specific terms. For example, a managed database, backup service or support contract can change who operates an individual component.

When should you choose SaaS?

Start with SaaS when a ready-made product supports the process, its access controls fit and the integrations you need are available. A small team that needs shared email and documents can configure an existing service instead of building those applications. The provider maintains the application, while the business manages its users and how its data is handled.

SaaS becomes a weaker fit when a required approval rule, data export or integration cannot be supported, or when the vendor’s limits prevent the workflow from working as needed. Test the specific task and export before assuming a feature list covers it.

When should you choose PaaS?

Choose PaaS for a custom application when its supported runtimes, deployment model and service limits meet your needs. The provider manages more of the underlying platform, so the team can focus on application behavior and data instead of patching every server.

You still need someone to maintain the code, handle failed integrations, review access, monitor the application and arrange recovery. Check background jobs, persistent storage, traffic limits and the services needed for backups. A managed platform reduces some operations; it does not supply a finished business application.

When should you choose IaaS?

Choose IaaS when the application needs control over its operating system, installed software or network configuration that a managed platform cannot provide. A legacy application with a required runtime or specialist configuration can be a reasonable starting case.

Your team or an appointed provider must maintain that additional control: patch and secure the guest operating system, deploy the application, monitor capacity and test recovery. A virtual machine alone does not guarantee backups or high availability. If the team cannot staff those duties, a managed service or a change to the application may be a better fit.

What does each model cost for the same workflow?

Compare the full cost of delivering the outcome, not only the cloud invoice. The following hypothetical US planning example assumes ten staff use the same approval workflow for a year. It assumes each option meets the same access, integration and recovery needs. Prices and work hours are invented for the calculation; they are not vendor quotes, market rates or a measured Hapy project.

Cost over the first yearSaaSCustom app on PaaSCustom app on IaaS
Setup or build$500 configuration$8,000 build$8,000 build
Service charges10 users × $20 × 12 = $2,400$80 × 12 = $960$60 × 12 = $720
Operating work at an assumed $50/hour2 hours/month × 12 = $1,2004 hours/month × 12 = $2,4008 hours/month × 12 = $4,800
First-year total$4,100$11,360$13,520

In this scenario, SaaS costs $7,260 less than PaaS because the example does not require a custom build. IaaS has the lowest assumed service bill but costs $2,160 more than PaaS overall because the example assigns more operating hours to it. Staff time represents capacity valued at the assumed rate; it is not necessarily cash saved. Actual hours, software limits, reliability needs, tax, migration and integration costs will change the result.

For a real estimate, include the same users, workload, storage, support hours and recovery requirements in each option. Include configuration or development, recurring charges, administration and a transition plan. Google Cloud’s pricing information shows why an infrastructure bill depends on usage and configuration; it does not provide the prices in the example above.

Who handles security and recovery?

The provider’s responsibility grows as it manages more of the service, but the customer does not stop making security decisions. Microsoft’s shared-responsibility guidance identifies data, identities and access as continuing customer concerns across cloud models. Confirm the details for the product and contract you buy.

For each service, name who can grant access, review permissions, apply patches within your scope, monitor failures, respond to incidents and restore data. Test an export and a recovery procedure using representative data. A provider’s uptime commitment does not by itself restore a record deleted by a user or repair a faulty application change.

How do you choose for your business?

For the ten-person approval workflow, first test a SaaS product against the essential approval path and data controls. If the workflow needs custom logic that the product cannot support, compare a PaaS app with its build and support costs. Consider IaaS when a concrete operating-system or network requirement makes that extra control useful and you have an owner for the additional work.

The right model can change as a product or team changes. Record the choice, operating owner and assumptions, then revisit them when the workload or responsibilities change. For the wider business decision, see cloud versus SaaS and enterprise application development. Hapy’s service options can help you discuss implementation and ongoing ownership.

Hamid

Choosing how to run your app?

Talk to Hamid about the control and support your business needs.

Further questions

Share with others